Update (October 2026)
This post reports a January 2018 court decision. Since then the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) has been replaced by the Administrative Review Tribunal (ART), from 14 October 2024, and the Federal Circuit Court became part of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia in September 2021. The principle from the case still matters: a genuine relationship does not have to be based on Western ideas of romantic love. See our Partner visa and visa refusal appeal pages for current rules.
A recent judgement was handed down on 23rd January 2018 by the Federal Circuit Court which set aside a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) (now the Administrative Review Tribunal) affirming the refusal of a Subclass 309 visa to a man from Macedonia.
This means the case had to go back to be reassessed and could not be refused on this basis again.
78. I would add that the Tribunal in this case seems to have considered that a
relationship can only satisfy the definition of a married relationship if it is based
on Western notions of romantic love. Obviously, there are millions of people
around the world who are in arranged and other marriages that are genuine and
continuing, but which are not based on romantic love.
79.The Tribunal also seems in this case to have considered that a married
relationship is genuine and continuing only if it accords with an inner
suburban, middle class aspiration of equality and sharing of financial and
other information. However, obviously, most genuine marriages around the
world to this day have an enormous power imbalance and many genuine
marriages, even in Australia, do not involve a complete sharing of financial
and other information. That is apparent from sitting in the family law
jurisdiction of this court.
http://www.austlii.edu.au/cgi-bin/viewdoc/au/cases/cth/FCCA/2018/121.html
What this means in 2026
The court in this case criticised the Tribunal for judging a marriage against Western, middle class ideas of romance and equal sharing of finances. That approach still guides how genuine relationships should be assessed today. Decision makers look at your relationship as a whole, and cultural differences, arranged marriages or a traditional division of roles do not by themselves mean a relationship is not genuine.
For a Partner visa, the Department of Home Affairs considers four areas of your relationship. You do not need perfect evidence in every area, but your application should explain your relationship in your own words and be backed by documents.
| Area | What the Department looks at | Examples of evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Financial | How you share or support each other financially | Joint accounts, money transfers, shared bills or assets |
| Household | How you live together and share responsibilities | Joint lease or mortgage, mail to the same address, care of children |
| Social | Whether others know you as a couple | Statements from family and friends, invitations, photos, travel together |
| Commitment | Your intention to stay together long term | Contact while apart, knowledge of each other, future plans, wills |
Partner visa applications are now reviewed by the Administrative Review Tribunal if they are refused. The onshore 820/801 applicant, or the Australian sponsor for an offshore 309/100 application, can usually apply for review, within the time limit stated in the refusal letter. From 1 July 2026 the Partner visa main applicant charge is AUD 11,710.
Next steps
- Write a joint relationship statement that explains how you met, your cultural background and how you share your life.
- Collect evidence across all four areas, and explain any gaps (for example, separate finances for cultural or practical reasons).
- Ask family and friends for statements that describe your relationship.
- If you receive a refusal, check the review deadline the same day and get advice.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need to prove romantic love for a Partner visa?
No. The law asks whether you have a mutual commitment to a shared life as a couple to the exclusion of all others, and whether the relationship is genuine and continuing. Arranged marriages and relationships with different cultural expectations can meet this test.
Are arranged marriages accepted for Partner visas?
Yes, as long as both partners gave real consent and the marriage is valid where it took place. See our guide on whether your marriage is valid for visa purposes.
Do we have to share all our finances?
No. Financial evidence is only one of four areas. Many genuine couples keep some finances separate. Explain your arrangements honestly and support them with evidence from the other areas.
What can I do if my Partner visa is refused?
You may be able to apply to the Administrative Review Tribunal for review. Strict time limits apply, so check your decision letter straight away and get advice. See visa refusal appeals.







Tasmania State Nomination Changes from 1 December: Mechanics, Massage Therapists and TSG
Working Holiday Visa Changes: New Regional Work Guarantee for Second and Third Visas
Condition 8503 to Apply to All Visitor Visas, ETAs and eVisitors
Applying for Another Visitor Visa From Inside Australia
Visiting Australia While Your Partner or Parent Visa Is Being Processed